Scott Gosselink

The Branch Davidians

 

KEYWORDS

 

Branch Davidians, Koresh, Howell, Houteff, Cult, Seven Seals, Waco, SDA, Adventist, Miller, Second Advent

 

I. ABSTRACT

The Davidians were formed in 1929 when Victor Houteff was expelled from the Seventh Day Adventist Church, a Christian movement that split from the Millerite movement after William Miller’s incorrect prediction of Christ’s Second Coming, for his apocalyptic interpretations of Daniel and Revelation.  The relatively small splinter sect of the Branch Davidians first emerged in the 1950s under the teachings of Benjamin Roden after Houteff’s wife incorrectly predicted the Second Advent.  

The Branch Davidians believe that the Bible is an inerrant prophetic text and that God will always send them a prophet to help guide them especially in the "Last Days" before Christ’s return because they feel that they are God's chosen people.  Through their messianic leader, the Davidians interpret the Bible as inerrant and practice strict rituals aimed at their ultimate salvation during Jesus’ return according to the Bible’s scriptures. 

 

II. SCOPE AND PURPOSE OF THE SYSTEM

The Davidians are a highly diverse social and economic, Christian based sect available to anyone who will strictly follow its teachings.   This openness for members created a multi-racial and multi-ethnic group spanning many countries.  Today there are only about a dozen active members of the Branch Davidians scattered throughout Europe, but during the movement’s peak there were upwards of 1000 members.  However, in February, 1993, under the rule David Koresh, the group’s demise came when their compound outside Waco was seized by the ATF for the stockpiling of weapons that Koresh had built up for the coming apocalypse and after a 51 day standoff, the siege ended with 55 Branch Davidians dying inside the burning complex (Thibodeau 258).  

The Branch Davidians concentrate on moving into the divinely ordained future, revealing the secrets of the seven seals, and awaiting the end of time with the Second Coming of Christ.  The Branch Davidians have worshipped 5 different prophets during their existence: Ben Roden, Lois Roden, David Koresh, Ellen White and Victor Houteff.  Each prophet adopted a messianic role believed essential to human salvation and ordaining the end of time (Barrett 119).  These five prophets help the Branch Davidians to see the “new light” during the last days when the end of the world would come upon Jesus’ return. 

Each prophet led the Davidians through a strictly Adventist perspective, and expanded their teachings from the preceding leader.  These leaders stressed the importance of a strict daily routine so that they would be prepared for Jesus’ return to Earth and would be spared from the looming apocalypse.  Also, the Branch Davidians believe that because these prophets kept the members “in the message” (Tabor 49) by educating the group on the newest teachings of God, the Branch Davidians would be resurrected into eternal life with God after the Second Advent. 

 

III. AUTHORITY STRUCTURE

a.      Sources and Criteria of Valid Knowledge

The sources of valid knowledge of the Davidians have changed through each of its four active “prophets.” (Ellen White never actively led the Davidians; she was influential in laying the guidelines that the SDA and consequently the Davidians follow). However, the original constitution of the group was laid out by Victor Houteff, and expanded on by all other prophets, clearly states that the Davidians embrace the core teachings of the Seventh Day Adventists (SDA). 

The SDA focuses its teachings on three main doctrines as inspired by Ellen White.  The first being that the date of the apocalypse set by William Miller in the 1840s was correct; however, it did not mark the return of Jesus to Earth, but rather that He had entered Heavenly sanctuary to cleanse it in preparation for the Judgment.  Secondly, they believe in innate mortality – the idea that when someone dies, they remain unconscious until resurrected by God, or annihilated.  A second resurrection will occur and the righteous will return to a newly cleansed world upon Jesus’ return to Earth.  Thirdly, the SDA stated that all Christians must obey the laws set forth by the Ten Commandments, including the retention of Saturday as their Sabbath.  Though this was widely abandoned in Christian teachings, the Davidians believed that it held equal importance as the other nine commandments and therefore should not be ignored.  Finally, the Adventists believed that in the last days before the Jesus’ return, the gift of prophecy would come upon the Church (Barrett 71).                       

Apart from Houteff’s stress on the SDA, his apocalyptic readings of the Bible caused him to emphasize the imminent establishment of the Kingdom of God.  He stressed that the Bible is a vast repository of secret and inviolable truths wherein typology and numerology offered keys to its hidden meanings.  Houteff tried to establish a “true church” of 144,000 believers (www.religioustolerance.org) to help unlock the hidden messages of the Bible before the Second Coming of Jesus.  He once said in accordance to his belief that the Bible is inerrant,  “every letter, word, and phrase of a sentence [of the Bible] has its appointed part to play in gibing coherent expression to the thought intended…in unfolding the Bible truths” (Wright 23).  These ideas were passed on through the next prophets of the group.

Houteff’s teachings continued through the group’s next spiritual leader, Ben Roden.  The writings of White and Houteff appeared in many of his teachings and publications.  Roden expanded from Houteff’s “true church” by aiming to reproduce the character of Christ in the lives of the elect 144,000 in preparation for the Second Coming; an idea referred to as Adventist perfectionism (Tabor 34).  However, the themes of the significance of Israel and an increased concern for the recovery of lost Israelite festivals appeared throughout Roden’s publications and not Houteff’s.  Because of this belief, he stressed the importance of recognizing the feast days.  For this reason, all Branch Davidians strictly followed Passover, Pentecost, Day of Atonement and Tabernacles (Barrett 120).

David Koresh, the fifth and final prophet of the Branch Davidians, expanded on the teachings of prior prophets as well as created new ideas.  He believed that he was the Lamb “having seven horns and seven eyes, which are the seven spirits of God sent forth into all the earth” (Revelations 5:7) that protected the scroll of the Seven Seals.  He took it upon himself to interpret the scroll and on accomplishing this task; he and his followers would be spared during the Second Advent.  Also, he said that through his prophetic status, he could spread the “seed” of God by taking on all members of the group as his “spiritual wives” in his home which he renamed the “House of David” (Samples 53).  He foresaw the apocalypse to come in 1995 with the Ranch Apocalypse as the center for the battle.  For this reason, Koresh and the Davidians stockpiled over 11 tons worth of weapons and ammunition.  However, this stockpile led to the compounds seizure and eventual destruction at the hands of the U.S. government.   

The remaining members of the Branch Davidians predicted that the Second Advent would occur 2,300 days, as described in Daniel, after Koresh’s death, but that date has since passed and the numbers of believers has dwindled to nearly nothing.

 

b.      Methods of Inquiry

The focus of the members of the Branch Davidian life is centered on religious rituals and worship.  The Davidians at Waco led a highly regulated and disciplined communal life.  They regulated information and no forms of competition were allowed within the compound to make sure that the members cooperated well as a group.  They rose early, ate together, grew their own food, and committed long intervals of time to Bible study.  However, even though the Bible was the group’s religious text, only the groups leader could interpret teach its meaning.  A Davidian once said, in defense of deferring to prophets, “Anybody who goes direct to the Bible and thinks that they can interpret is just deceiving themselves…It is written by inspiration and must be understood by inspiration” (Wright 35).  For this reason, the Davidians willfully partook in routinely held services on Friday evenings and Saturday afternoons, as well as mandatory instructional classes held each evening.  The prophets led the sessions, preaching, prophesizing and inspiring the Davidians to become spellbound by the Bible’s teachings. 

The group places a strong emphasis on health that focused primarily on a diet.  Davidians are expected to withhold a diet as interpreted in the Old Testament; most became vegetarian.  The group also believed that physical labor built character and contributed to sharing and enriching communal life (55).  The leaders required everyone at the compound to work, no matter the age, and provided them with wages.  However, some also worked outside jobs to help support the religious group. 

The leaders emphasized separation from the outer world and focused on community practices.  The allowing of members to work to help fund the compound was the Davidians only dependency on the outside world.  To further stress the importance of segregation, the Branch Davidians had separate currency from the outside world, and created separate educational programs to prevent socialization of the young.  Children were required to learn the basic aspects of the Davidian faith, namely the Bible and the teachings of Ellen White, as well as master a practical skill that would further their importance to the group (27).  It also continued influence into religious endogamy in which members were not permitted to marry someone of a different faith.  Many Davidians divorced upon entering the group. 

Another practice focuses on attire. Women were required to wear dresses of length between the knees and feet.  Exposure of any part of the female anatomy was discouraged.  Women did not wear makeup and kept their hair long (www.religioustolerance.org).  All these practices kept the Branch Davidians in an environment that enabled their full devotion towards their leader’s word.  Even though there lacked physical evidence, or proof, of these practices aimed toward aiding their salvation upon the Second Advent, the mere fact that their leader told the group to follow these practices was reason enough to follow his orders because his prophetic status made his word parallel with God’s.

 

c.       Institutions and Professional Structure

The Davidians can be separated into three main periods: under the control of Victor Houteff (The Shepherd’s Rod), under control of Ben and Lois Roden (The Branch Davidians), and finally under the control of David Koresh (The Students of the Seven Seals). However, the basis of authority continued throughout the groups existence remained the same.  It stated that the leader was able to claim to prophetic interpretation and revelation and have the acceptance of that claim as legitimate by all others in the community (Wright 24).  These four leaders all were authoritative figures.

At the beginning, Houteff was the undisputed leader of the sect.  There was a council of four officers, but all decisions must be approved by Houteff.  His power was enhanced by the fact that family members held other positions of power within the compound.  This convergence of family support and religious devotion provided support for the Davidian leader.  However, his most powerful aspect as a leader was his ability to inspire in his followers a deep sense of sacrifice and devotion.  He led his followers to say “We believe…with all our heart…that Brother Houteff is a prophet of God” (26) This belief helps to explain the reasoning behind the members’ sacrifice, commitment and cohesiveness necessary to the survival of the group. 

Roden built on the ideas that had preceded him.  He believed that he was the third and final prophet.  He thought of himself as king and patriarch of the community of saints, just as the biblical King David had been.  In fact, he proclaimed himself to be King David’s successor. Because of this idea, he believed that he deserved the complete authority over all Branch Davidians.  One member of his group later said that “Ben Roden is the King…. [and] I’m subject to Ben Roden” (White 35).  After his death, his wife, Lois Roden, the fourth and only female prophet, took control of the group.  She believed that the final part of the Trinity, the Holy Spirit, was feminine.  Following her belief, she preached God’s femininity and proclaimed that God would return to Earth as a woman during the Second Advent (Tabor 40).  David Koresh allied with Lois, but merely as a political move and not because they shared the same beliefs.

David Koresh quickly gained influence in the group after Lois Roden proclaimed him to be the fifth prophet.    Koresh, on top of being the Lamb mentioned in Revelations 5:7, also believed that he was King David and thus deserved the complete obedience.  The Mighty Men were Koresh’s lieutenants who held various organizational and leadership responsibilities to help Koresh (62).  Though each leader took individual approaches to leading the group, they all were regarded with the same prophetic status and therefore a completely authoritative role.

 

IV. HISTORY

            The Branch Davidians is a splinter sect that broke away from the Seventh Day Adventist Church in 1942.  The breakaway sect of the SDA that proved to aid in forming the Branch Davidians was founded by Victor Houteff, who joined the SDA in 1919 and was later expelled for his apocalyptic interpretations of the Daniel and Revelations.  He never had intention of forming a new denomination, but intended to reform an old one (Wright 22-23).  However, the church disallowed his intended reformation and with about 30 members, Houteff moved from Los Angeles to Waco and set up a movement called “The Shepherd’s Rod” (24).

In Waco, the group renamed itself the Davidian Seventh Day Adventist, after the Kingdom of David.  After Houteff’s death, his wife, Florence, took leadership of the movement and prophesized that that Christ would return on April 22, 1959 according to the 1,260 days of Revelation 11 would be completed on this date.  When the Second Coming failed to occur, the group fragmented to form several different groups.  Benjamin Roden, the next leader, told his followers to “Get off the dead Rod and move on to a living Branch,” (Barrett 119) and thus called his group the Branch Davidians.

Roden’s most recognizable contribution was an insignia to represent their beliefs.  It was a circular field filled with a Star of David and twelve perimeter stars. "Ensign" was written across the center and the reference "Isaiah 11:1" was placed underneath it. Superimposed upon the design was a plant with three designations: Jesse the Stem, David the Rod, and Christ the Branch (www.religioustolerance.org).

Roden’s wife, Lois, took over control of the group in their compound in Waco, Mt. Carmel, after her husband’s passing in 1978.  Her son, George, did not agree with his mother’s teachings and proclaimed himself to be the messiah.  Vernon Howell joined the Branch Davidians in 1981 and, although clashed with George Roden, Lois proclaimed, partly due to the two’s sexual relationship, Howell to be the group’s next prophet.  Because of her proclamation, he quickly worked into a position of influence (Tabor 40).  Howell then confronted George Roden with a band of about 8 men and Roden was arrested for violating a restraining order and contempt of court after he was wounded in a gun battle between him and Howell.  After Roden’s capture, Howell took control of the movement.

Immediately after his rise to power, Howell amassed an international recruitment drive in 1985.  Howell’s charm, good looks, and ability to serenade with the guitar helped him quickly gain the devotion from the members (Thibodeau 20).  The number of members residing in Ranch Apocalypse peaked at 130 members in 1993. 

Under the rule of Howell, the community adopted a much stronger communal form of organization with him as the leader.  Vernon Howell changed his name to David Koresh in 1990.  David was named after King David of the Israelites and Koresh after the Babylonian King Cyrus (www.religioustolerance.org).  Under his rule, the Davidians, also known as the Students of the Seven Seals, continued their Adventist beliefs.  He renamed Mt. Carmel to Ranch Apocalypse after the belief that they must prepare for the coming of the apocalypse.   

In February of 1993, the Federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (ATF) raided the compound in Waco looking for firearms in which Koresh had been storing for the coming apocalypse.  A gunfight ensued in which four ATF agents died and six Branch Davidians were killed.  The FBI then laid siege to the compound and a 51 day standoff ended when Koresh and 54 fellow Branch Davidians were killed after the FBI’s tanks caused the stockpiled weapons to explode. (Thibodeau 258) Today, it is believed that only about dozen Branch Davidians still exist in the world -most residing and worshiping in Europe.

 

V. REPRESENTATIVE EXAMPLES OF ARGUMENTATION

            The Branch Davidians defended their belief of the immanency of the Second Advent through their basis in millenarian teachings.  William Miller, originally a farmer from New York, interpreted the Bible as a prophetic text and preached his beliefs across the country in the mid 19th century.  The main focus of his preachings was the Second Coming of Jesus.  He argued that from the passage in Daniel 8:14 that stated, “And he said onto me, unto 2,300 days, then shall the sanctuary be cleansed” that the Second Advent would occur between the spring equinoxes of 1843 and 1844.  This spawned from the belief that each “day” mentioned in the passage had duration of one year and the count began in 487 CE.  (Dick 165) When this date passed and the Second Advent did not occur, he blamed it on incorrect calculations and not that his interpretation of the passage was incorrect.  He believed that the beginning date or interpretation of the duration of “days” was incorrect. 

Since this “Great Disappointment,” the Davidians has used Daniel to prophesize the Second Advent after Roden’s and Koresh’s deaths, each time using the excuse of miscalculations for failed predictions.  Each prediction started from a different date, but followed the same passage that Miller believed would bring Jesus’ Second Coming.

 

VI. SUGGESTED POSITION IN COMPARATIVE SCALES

a.      Traditional Authority (1) à Testimony of Experience (10) – 2

The Branch Davidians rely strictly on the Bible as their teachings.  For this reason, they place nearly all their beliefs on traditional authority.   Their belief in the complete inerrancy of the Bible further portrays their emphasis on traditional authority over experience.  

b.      Centralization of Authority (1) à Decentralization (10) – 2

The Students of the Seven Seals relied heavily upon a leader in which they believed was a prophet provided by God.  The members regarded this person’s preaching to be on par with the Bible and therefore they were to follow his management.

c.       Emphasis on Spiritual Realities (1) à Material, Earthly Realities (10) – 3

The Branch Davidians believed in the existence on spiritual realities.  They, like all Christians, believed in the concept of the Trinity.  However, the Davidians held the idea that God would always send them a prophet who would lead the members on Earth into Heaven, showing the Earthly realities of the group.

d.      Spiritual or Moral Objectives (1) à Pragmatic Aims (10) – 3

The Branch Davidians follow a very strict and conservative interpretation of the Bible.  Therefore they comply with the most conventional Christian beliefs such as the Ten Commandments, the virgin birth, the infallibility of the Scripture, etc.  This causes them to focus on many spiritual objectives; however, their belief that their sanctity during Christ’s Second Coming would allow them to ascend to heaven shows the purposefulness of their practices.

e.      Power Reserved for Divine Beings (1) à Individual Power (10) – 5

Although the Branch Davidians followed the guidance of spiritual leader, they believed that these people had extraordinary powers.  The leaders were prophets whose word was regarded nearly equal with the Bible because he was provided by God.  Obedience to these living prophets would spare them during Christ’s Second Coming.

 

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY

 

I.                   Primary Sources

 

The Holy Bible: Authorized King James Version. New York: Oxford University Press, 1945.

Shows sacred text of the Branch Davidians and allows the interpretations of the text by the group to be recognized.

 

Thibodeau, David, and Whiteson, Leon. A Place Called Waco: A Survivors Story. New York: Public Affairs, 1999.

This book is written by David Thibodeau, one only four member of the Branch Davidians who survived the massacre in Waco and was not sentenced to jail.  Gives his perspective from inside the complex and recaps the days leading up to massacre.

 

 

II.                Secondary Sources

 

Barrett, David. Sects, “Cults” and Alternative Religions. New York: Sterling Publishing, 1996.
This book explains many different alternative religions in detail.  Has two parts that focus on the Branch Davidians.  Most helpful in describing the history and some aspects of the beliefs of the Branch Davidians.
 
“Branch Davidians: a.k.a. The Students of the Seven Seals.” 1995-2001 Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance 2 Nov. 2001. <http://www.religioustolerance.org/dc_branc.htm>

Website outlines fundamental beliefs and ideas as well as a brief history of the group.

 

Dick, Everett N. William Miller and the Advent Crisis. Berrien Springs, MI : Andrews University Press, 1994

This site gave me an insight on the affect of William Miller on the SDA.

 

Numbers, Ronald, and Butler, Jonathan. The Disappointed. Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1987.

Although it does not explain the Branch Davidians because it was written before 1993, it gives explanation behind the Millenarianism movement which the Branch Davidians expanded from.

 

Saliba, John. Understanding New Religious Movements. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1995.

This book provides insight on the history of new religious movements in the West as well as the psychological, sociological and theological reasons for the new religions.

 

Samples, Kenneth, de Castro, Erwin, Abanes, Richard, and Lyle, Robert. Prophets of the Apocalypse: David Koresh and Other American Messiahs. Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1994.

This book helps to explain the reasoning behind self proclaimed prophets. Koresh’s actions as well as beliefs leading up to Waco are described in detail.

 

Tabor, James, and Gallagher, Eugene. Why Waco?. London: University of California Press, 1995.

This book is written to confront the misconceptions of cults.  It tries to accurately display the actions of Koresh and his followers to explain contemporary religious movements in America.  It also gives good examples of argumentation.

 

Wright, Stuart. Armageddon in Waco: Critical Perspectives on the Branch Davidian Conflict.  London: University of Chicago Press, 1995.

Breaks up the book into six parts about the Branch Davidians, the one I focused on dealt with the social and historical context of the cult.